Shopping Guide for AEDs: Zoll vs. Philips HeartStart for British Columbia Businesses
Buying Guide: Zoll vs. Philips AED
Choosing the right Automated External Defibrillator (AED) can make a life-saving difference in emergencies. Here’s a guide to help British Columbia businesses select an AED that fits their needs, focusing on two popular options: Zoll and Philips HeartStart.
Key Considerations
- Ease of Use: AEDs should be easy for anyone to operate, even with minimal training.
- Durability: Businesses need AEDs that withstand varying environments, from offices to construction sites.
- Maintenance and Battery Life: AEDs should be low maintenance with reliable battery life.
- Cost and Accessories: Consider the unit’s cost, replacement pads, and additional accessories.
Zoll AEDs
Zoll is known for its focus on intuitive user guidance and durability.
Pros of Zoll AEDs:
- Real CPR Help: Zoll AEDs provide real-time feedback on the depth and rate of chest compressions, which can be essential during high-stress situations.
- Rugged Design: Built for challenging environments, Zoll AEDs are durable and dust- and water-resistant.
- Long-Life Battery: Zoll models often feature a long-life lithium battery that requires less frequent replacement.
Recommended Models:
- Zoll AED Plus: User-friendly with Real CPR Help and clear voice prompts.
- Zoll AED 3: Includes WiFi connectivity for seamless device management and is suitable for high-traffic areas.
Philips HeartStart AEDs
Philips HeartStart AEDs are trusted for their simplicity and accessibility, ideal for businesses with varying levels of user experience.
Pros of Philips HeartStart AEDs:
- Quick Start-Up: Designed for speed, Philips AEDs start quickly and automatically analyze the heart rhythm once pads are placed.
- Easy-to-Follow Guidance: Step-by-step voice commands guide users, making them ideal for employees with little training.
- Flexible Pad Options: Compatible with both adult and pediatric pads, Philips AEDs are versatile for businesses with mixed-age groups.
Recommended Models:
- Philips HeartStart OnSite: Portable and easy to use, with a pre-installed battery and pads for quick deployment.
- Philips HeartStart FRx: Offers optional infant/child key for simplified pediatric use and durable design.
Comparison Chart: Zoll AED vs. Philips HeartStart
| Feature | Zoll AED (AED Plus, AED 3) | Philips HeartStart (OnSite, FRx) |
|---|---|---|
| CPR Guidance | Real-time feedback with Real CPR Help | Voice prompts without compression feedback |
| Ease of Use | Clear voice instructions and graphics | Simple voice prompts, ideal for beginners |
| Durability | Dust and water-resistant, rugged build | FRx is durable, OnSite suitable for offices |
| Battery Life | Long-lasting lithium battery | Replaceable, up to 4 years |
| Connectivity | AED 3 features WiFi for easy management | None |
| Pediatric Options | Adult and pediatric pads available | Infant/Child key with FRx |
| Cost | Slightly higher price point | Mid-range pricing |
Visual Aid: A decision tree visual can help businesses choose between the two options:
- Is ease of use your priority?
- Yes → Philips HeartStart
- No → Continue to Question 2
- Do you need real-time CPR guidance?
- Yes → Zoll AED
- No → Philips HeartStart
- Will it be in a rugged environment?
- Yes → Zoll AED or Philips FRx
- No → Any model
Final Tips
For businesses, accessibility and durability are essential in AED selection. Zoll provides robust real-time feedback, while Philips is known for ease of use and reliability, especially in public spaces with diverse users.
This guide should help British Columbia businesses make an informed AED purchase.